New Buffalo Vacation Rentals

Our New Buffalo Collection of vacation rentals is the origination of Juniper Holiday + Home. This custom-curated selection of luxury vacation rentals in New Buffalo showcases thoughtfully designed homes with deluxe amenities and prime locations both lakefront and downtown. Backed by exceptional service and unwavering quality we invite you to stay with us in one of our many New Buffalo Michigan rentals.

Properties Available 13 properties available
Spacious New Buffalo 4BR/4BA vacation home w/ OMG Lake MI views! Just a few blks from downtown shops, cafes + beach! 3 floors, 2 kitchens, lush social areas + lg backyard. Kitchen on main floor opens to DR w/ fireplace, leading to huge screened porch. 3 well-appointed BRs + 2 full BAs on this level. Upstairs is a Great Room, stone fireplace, wet ba
Sunset Dream
House Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Guests 12 guests
Rating 4.9 (87)
This stunning, fully renovated 4BR-3BA home, with its open floor plan, vaulted ceilings, great natural light and stylish, yet cozy furnishings invites you to step into a true dream vacation! All sorts of features ensure a fabulous time for all: plenty of comfy seating, two large flat-screen TVs, a game room, fully-equipped kitchen and breakfast bar
Destination Dogwood
House Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 5 (8)
Rich design 6 BR/5 BA home near New Buffalo Harbor + beaches. Great Room w/ stone fireplace. Chef’s kitchen w/ marble-top island. 3-season sunroom. Elegant-comfy furniture. Master BR has stone fireplace + BA w/ twin sinks, tile walk-in shower + jacuzzi. Lower-level Guest BR has fireplace, full BA, game room + posh screening room. 2nd floor has loft
The Moose House
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Guests 14 guests
Rating 4.9 (150)
Vaulted ceilings, wood floors and beams enhance this 4 BR/2.5 BA home! Stylish Great Room w/ stone fireplace. 2 enclosed patios w/ wood views. Kitchen has wraparound granite top + hi-end appliances. All 4 BRs are well-appointed + cozy. 2 twin-sink vanities, stone tile BAs + a half-bath, with 2 King beds, a Queen and 2 twin-beds. Each floor has a co
Wild Horse Run
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (105)
Stay at a breathtaking luxury home perched on the edge of Lake Michigan, loaded w/ upgrades + amenities! Your own private beach, 2 decks, lake view windows, a fireplace, all nestled on a bluff w/ million-dollar views. Add a Chef’s kitchen w/ high-end appliances, a custom dining table that can seat 12, an intimate LR and sitting room + a screened po
The Shore House
House Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Guests 12 guests
Rating 5 (48)
Exquisite 4BR/2BA vacation home in wooded area 1 blk from Lake MI private beach. Richly designed w/ cathedral ceilings, skylights, Great Room + fireplace, hardwood floors, curated furnishings. Hi-end pro kitchen has porcelain counters, prep island, leads to elegant dining space. All 4 BRs are chic-comfy: 3 downstairs (1 King + 2 Qn) + 1 loft-style
The Songbird
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 5 (68)
Fabulous views of Lake Michigan are both inside and out of this New Buffalo 3BR/2BA vacation home. With a sunroom and 3 walls of windows for viewing the lake and expansive backyard, plus a deck w/ a grill, you can't miss! Add chic-and-comfy furnishings and a fireplace, plus a kitchen featuring custom wood cabinets, white marble island and deck acce
Lake Michigan Getaway
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 6 guests
Rating 5 (102)
This gorgeous New Buffalo home set in serene woods is a great vacay getaway! Beautifully designed and comfy-cozy, the spacious open design features a Hearth Room w/ fireplace + Smart TV where everyone can joyfully gather. All you need for creating great meals is in the fully equipped modern kitchen, and eating-seating options abound in the stylish
The High Life
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (2)
Panoramic views of Lake MI from floor-to-ceiling windows are only the beginning! A mixture of Midcentury Modern design and warm wood tones create an inviting lakefront enclave for families and friends. Large grassy backyard, sun deck leading to private beach, outdoor shower! Interior open social spaces overlook Lake MI. Main ensuite has queen bed +
Keck Hill
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 5 (16)
This adorable "cottage" has 4BRs/2BAs and is in a private neighborhood w/ its own pool. Near downtown restaurants, shops + beach. A fully equipped kitchen has lots of space and there's a stone fireplace. The main floor Master BR has a King bed w/ full ensuite bath. Upstairs is a lounge area w/ Xbox and 3 BRs including a King bed, a Queen bed and on
Schoolhouse Rock
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 5 (9)
Whether you need a staycation, workcation, or a getaway, Deer Haus awaits your next adventure. The tranquil cottage is nestled in the woods and yet strikingly close to the heart of New Buffalo. Deer Haus is only half a mile from downtown New Buffalo’s restaurants and breweries, great for a bike ride. Pack up your car or continue to pedal another mi
Deer Haus
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half baths
Guests 6 guests
Rating 4.9 (16)
Across from New Buffalo Harbor and a short walk to a stunning beach and city park, Harbor Haven is a dreamy vacay condo in the heart of a popular vacation district. With great harbor views, stylish-yet-comfy furnishings throughout, nicely-appointed BRs and BAs, a sweet kitchen with high-end appliances, and an awesome back deck, you'll find R-and-R
New Buffalo Harbor Haven
Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Guests 6 guests

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

I agree